DISCLAIMER: Potterworld or Droobledore LLC is not in any way affiliated with Mojang AB, J.K. Rowling, Warner Brothers or any company, copyright or trademark.
PotterworldMC PotterworldMC PotterworldMC

Doors and exploration

ShareYourHead

New Magician
Minecraft IGN: ShareYourHead
Raven
#1
I feel like there should be a thing that automatically closes every door that's been open for a while. Similar to how locked doors shut again automatically, but this would last more like 5 minutes.

This may seem minor, but several times I've been exploring and suddenly I see a door that's already open. This makes me realize that people have already been where I am, and makes my discovery seem less special (of course I know that probably every corner of the map has been scrutinized, but still it messes up my excitement in the moment).
This can also take away some of the challenge of exploration. It's as if all you have to do it follow the trail of open doors in an area and you'll find what you're looking for. This may be nice for some but to me it just defeats the purpose of finding your way somewhere.
And finally (And probably the biggest thing) having all the doors be open all the time just makes the world feel empty and abandoned. It feels like nothing changes since you were in a spot the day before. granted it likely hasn't had anything happen but still. Like why would the train conductor just let the door on the passenger car stay open. or why would all the bathroom doors be open at all times.

Tl;dr: It's annoying that doors don't close automatically for two reasons. Finding an open door makes the discovery on the other side seem less special, and having so many doors just open for no reason makes the world feel abandoned.

Idk maybe this whole thing doesn't make sense. plz let me know if you agree. thanks for reading :)
 
Last edited:

MamaDuckie

Head of Media
Head Staff
Staff
Minecraft IGN: MamaDuckie
Staff Head Staff Raven Linked
#3
'ello there!

Thank you for your suggestion! I actually have the same issue with doors(both in rl and in-game!) and am really excited about this suggestion you've made! I'm going to bring this up with the rest of the Poltergeist team to get their opinions on it and see how possible it is! Sit tight, I'll get back to you soon as I can!
 

MamaDuckie

Head of Media
Head Staff
Staff
Minecraft IGN: MamaDuckie
Staff Head Staff Raven Linked
#4
'ello!

After reviewing your suggestion with the rest of the team, I come bearing a decision and news! The team have decided that you've made some wonderful points in your suggestion and we entirely agree with you on it. Having doors being open does reduce the feel of exploration and we will be looking into adding this in the future. Unfortunately, while we are going to look at it, it's not currently at the top of our to-do list and we do have other priorities to deal with beforehand. We'll come back to this at a later date to see if this suggestion is a reachable goal.

Again, thank you for your suggestion and we hope to hear more from you in the future!
 

Zadanthalion

Animorphus
Minecraft IGN: ZADANeth
Dark Follower Griffin Phoenix
#6
I feel like there should be a thing that automatically closes every door that's been open for a while. Similar to how locked doors shut again automatically, but this would last more like 5 minutes.

This may seem minor, but several times I've been exploring and suddenly I see a door that's already open. This makes me realize that people have already been where I am, and makes my discovery seem less special (of course I know that probably every corner of the map has been scrutinized, but still it messes up my excitement in the moment).
This can also take away some of the challenge of exploration. It's as if all you have to do it follow the trail of open doors in an area and you'll find what you're looking for. This may be nice for some but to me it just defeats the purpose of finding your way somewhere.
And finally (And probably the biggest thing) having all the doors be open all the time just makes the world feel empty and abandoned. It feels like nothing changes since you were in a spot the day before. granted it likely hasn't had anything happen but still. Like why would the train conductor just let the door on the passenger car stay open. or why would all the bathroom doors be open at all times.

Tl;dr: It's annoying that doors don't close automatically for two reasons. Finding an open door makes the discovery on the other side seem less special, and having so many doors just open for no reason makes the world feel abandoned.

Idk maybe this whole thing doesn't make sense. plz let me know if you agree. thanks for reading :)
I feel this. Especially the piece about feeling like all the open doors makes them useless and the world feel abandoned. If they're just open all the time, why not just take them out entirely. But I think your suggestion is a great idea!
 

Buttery_Flapjack

New Magician
Staff
Minecraft IGN: Buttery_Flapjack
Auralock Dark Follower Staff Griffin Phoenix Poltergeist Linked
#7
Hello @ShareYourHead,

Unfortunately this suggestion has been changed to a decline. We don't see the automatic closing of doors as a necessary addition and it may instead cause a burden to players who play together in a group, or confuse our newer players. As a general standard when building our maps, we ensure to have all doors closed. This is so that when the worlds are restarted, they being with all of their doors closed, and revert back to this when a new world comes online.

Nevertheless we thank you for this suggestion and hope you have a good day!