A few suggestions and feedback on guilds:
1. Since there were talks on discord about the amount of members in a guild and how that effects the future gameplay, I wanna say a couple of things.
I don't think the amount of players should have a big impact on the gameplay that is planned. This is because I believe guilds shouldnt be about quantity of members and amount of gold - but more about friends and common goals. People should be motivated to join guilds they actually feel attracted to in some way, and not because a guild is on the /guild top. Also there's families that wanna have a guild, but only a few members that realistically would join - so why should those suffer if the gameplay gives advantage to big guilds.
When it comes to the max limit itself, 50 people seems unreasonable to me, i think it should be lowered. This is a server that averages less than 100 online players at a time, so 50 players seems like a lot.
2. House/Allegiance guilds
I'm against the idea of guilds using official Potterworlds terms of groups as a form of promotion for their guild, and claim it as their own. This creates a bit of confusion because those are *unofficial* guilds that appear otherwise. It's dividing players within the group itself, all members of the official group are tempted to join the guild and the people who don't join get left out from something that we all, as members of that specific group, should be a part of. I think those guilds should rename themselves to make it more guild like, for example "Griffin fanclub" or something like that (this is just a dumb example) so that it's clear that those are not official groups.
3. There should be a more clear way to monitor gold within a guild, so the members know exactly who gave/withdrew a certain amount (credits to Matty)
4. Guild housings and storage
I suggested something similar before, and I believe it got accepted, but I'll repeat it here again (maybe it's a bit different than the original suggestion tho). Please make it so we can allow people to only view chest, but not take the items. Having 50ish people is impossible to monitor when you have one storage, so I think it would be good if we could allow everyone to build, but not take the items from chests.
1. Since there were talks on discord about the amount of members in a guild and how that effects the future gameplay, I wanna say a couple of things.
I don't think the amount of players should have a big impact on the gameplay that is planned. This is because I believe guilds shouldnt be about quantity of members and amount of gold - but more about friends and common goals. People should be motivated to join guilds they actually feel attracted to in some way, and not because a guild is on the /guild top. Also there's families that wanna have a guild, but only a few members that realistically would join - so why should those suffer if the gameplay gives advantage to big guilds.
When it comes to the max limit itself, 50 people seems unreasonable to me, i think it should be lowered. This is a server that averages less than 100 online players at a time, so 50 players seems like a lot.
2. House/Allegiance guilds
I'm against the idea of guilds using official Potterworlds terms of groups as a form of promotion for their guild, and claim it as their own. This creates a bit of confusion because those are *unofficial* guilds that appear otherwise. It's dividing players within the group itself, all members of the official group are tempted to join the guild and the people who don't join get left out from something that we all, as members of that specific group, should be a part of. I think those guilds should rename themselves to make it more guild like, for example "Griffin fanclub" or something like that (this is just a dumb example) so that it's clear that those are not official groups.
3. There should be a more clear way to monitor gold within a guild, so the members know exactly who gave/withdrew a certain amount (credits to Matty)
4. Guild housings and storage
I suggested something similar before, and I believe it got accepted, but I'll repeat it here again (maybe it's a bit different than the original suggestion tho). Please make it so we can allow people to only view chest, but not take the items. Having 50ish people is impossible to monitor when you have one storage, so I think it would be good if we could allow everyone to build, but not take the items from chests.
Last edited: