I won't write all the same stuff again how forums suck, how polts have horrible communcation with players etc. This thread is just a bunch of links to other threads that weren't given justice. Ignored, unclear, wrong.. you name it and it's here. I've added some extra ideas and expect the ideas I have already given in the past to now be officially reviewed. I hope this also highlights the reason why players don't use forums (regardless of the time needed for threads to be reviewed) and why some people are disappointed with the server. This is mostly my own threads so if someone wants to add theirs, you're more than welcome.
1. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/suggestions.11305/ The whole discussion on the thread was ignored, as well as my last comment. Was promised an official reply and never got it. Some time after this thread someone else got the credit of making the same idea we discussed.
2. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bunch-of-suggestions.7132/ I feel like this thread was completely overlooked in the end, the thread was mostly accepted but a lot of those ideas never came to life, also some people suggested the same stuff I got declined for, so revisit the whole thread
3. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/stop-degrading-potions.13841/ On hold, but it is still happening, Arne who supposedly made most of those potions wasn't even aware of the thread
4. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bag-pouches-suggestion.13170/ Declined but both the Plushie bag and chocolate frog card book was implemented, promised a reply for the plushie bag and never got it
5. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/toggle-visibility-choose-your-own-view.15929/ - My idea was implemented but declined, I've suggested this way before I was forced to make a thread because I was ignored on other threads & Ariel never reached back about it
(Commented on original thread here - https://potterworldmc.com/threads/option-to-turn-off-player-visibility-in-flying.7713/ as well as here https://potterworldmc.com/threads/ditch-2x2-flying-hoops.15746/#post-94760 where I was simply ignored)
6. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/a...ple-alts-in-classes-ces-etc.12370/#post-80321 Completed but was never enforced in classes regularly, and consindering the discussion on this thread (https://potterworldmc.com/threads/house-boosting.16514/#post-97881) as well as many others, it should be revisited
7. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/event-scarfs.9048/#post-67549 Completed but wasn't followed through, you gave out the same scarves which made me make the thread at the time
8. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/banner-texture.12470/#post-81311 Completed, I'm still not fully happy with the redesign in a way that I think that the Hogwarts Banners should also have a background design like the House Banners do, because the logo on it's own is a bit empty. Also a bit off topic, but I'll officially make a suggestion here - Banner designs should not repeat, there's way than enough designs that can be used even if we stick with just a simple fade (personally made a banner sheet so that it's easy for staff to check which designs do exist so far https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...RX3MDn_cYrZ-zehnJ70IM/edit?pli=1#gid=29900023 )
9. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/rotation-of-dailies.14799/ Completed but I said how they should be fully randomized, not just a rotation. Won't get into details why that is better, it's worthless because it always gets overlooked. More dailies generally should be added. Also consider what I said in 2024 edit of this thread at the end about "daily blockers" https://potterworldmc.com/threads/leveling-then-vs-now.13872/#post-93616
10. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/the-balancing-of-the-extra-credit-activities.14644/ Kamer's and my comment got ignored, I believe it should be done. I won't repeat what I said there but this will be my official suggestion and a thread for it.
11. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/butterbrew-in-the-broomsticks-inn.15442/ Smaller thread but my comment got ignored
12, https://potterworldmc.com/threads/m...-in-the-guardian-quest-pt-4.14148/#post-88350 Completed but my comment got ignored, again, I'm suggesting for all the natural damages to be revisited.
13. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/new-arenas.11749/#post-82624 I originally suggested the dummy arena which was declined, but later on this thread https://potterworldmc.com/threads/add-dummy-to-dueling-classroom-to-test-damage.13907/ got accepted and completed.
14. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/fix-dueling.13873/ Lag is worse than ever
15. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/staff-items.8212/ Completed but there is so much inconsistency still. Potterworld needs to realize that before things didn't work like they work nowadays and items that were available for all players should never be taken away.
16. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/revert-to-the-old-potion-making-system.15148/ the last comment on the thread I made was seemingly ignored, but it is something I'm still standing behind today and I wrote there what I want to see in the new system so this will be my official thread for that idea.
17. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/put-an-end-to-events.15732/#post-94704 Declined as expected, but I wanna comment on by saying that I do believe events can be small and be successful (I genuinely enjoyed spring 2024 for example). I believe this is partially what PW should be doing in future. And my second suggestion regarding future of events is to possibly use permanent gameplay as a way of to kick off and celebrate an event (something like Azkaban in 2016, it was lauched during Halloween and then stayed there afterwards, it could be done again with Azkaban or Magical maze for anniversary)
18. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bring-back-the-decoration-of-the-courtyard-for-events.8423/ Also regarding events like the thread above, this time I ask the staff team to reconsider this decision as it's been proven that players do miss the decoration and it's definetely something that can be done for smaller events in future, rather than making any type of event builds .
19. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/a-suggestion-for-adding-parkour-spells-to-potterworldmc.14839/ Declined but I feel like my comment and idea was ignored, I discussed protego duo with Jacquas but never heard back, also a gliding spell would be dope.
20. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/make-daily-reward-claiming-automatic.13109/ Declined, generally I think the reasoning is a bit stupid, either way my last comment and alternative idea was ignored
21. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/more-chatter.14284/ Declined, but I would reconsider the decision, as well as thinking of an alternative. Just anything that happens automatically on the server that players can do on their own (something similar to Pierre, not literally the same thing but just something that happens automatically, it could be just a question in chat or something that players look for in game or epic chests appearing, literally anything)
22. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/class-and-arena-rules-automation.11702/ The discussion on the thread was unsurprisingly ignored again, I understand it's not easy to follow up with such threads but then what's the point of people discussing ideas anyway, if it's always gonna be ignored. At this point, I would seriously consider doing some sort of "automated class". Maybe it doesn't have to be labeled or be an actual class, but with the lack of overall activity on the server, something like this could be worth investing in. I know other HP servers have automated classes, and many servers generally have some automated happening.
23. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bring-remembering-survival-spell-back.9603/ Implemented but I was declined
23. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/budleigh-babberton-as-a-future-town.4840/ Recently declined suggestion, the reasoning doesn't make sense. Cease and desist should not be an excuse to build a small town like the many random towns we have already, and make some lore for it to reflect on the original. Let's not forget why the lore team is here, and what potterworld is.
24. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/i...e-dark-prison-as-a-gauntlet.12799/#post-98162 You keep crediting this person for the idea I originally suggested. EDIT - the threads got updated and declined because of cease and desist that limits the promotion of new content. Old azkaban was superior simply because of the gameplay, evergreen at that. It was more friendly to players of all levels since almost anyone could run through mobs or kill them as they were one shot. Repressed Evil is also happening in a canon location and I'm sure there's several ways to still promote the content. After all, the limited promotion outside the game isn't a good enough reason for me to just dismiss one of the best PW contents ever. Link to my original thread https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bring-back-azkaban.10865/
Enjoy polts, make it right this time
1. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/suggestions.11305/ The whole discussion on the thread was ignored, as well as my last comment. Was promised an official reply and never got it. Some time after this thread someone else got the credit of making the same idea we discussed.
2. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bunch-of-suggestions.7132/ I feel like this thread was completely overlooked in the end, the thread was mostly accepted but a lot of those ideas never came to life, also some people suggested the same stuff I got declined for, so revisit the whole thread
3. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/stop-degrading-potions.13841/ On hold, but it is still happening, Arne who supposedly made most of those potions wasn't even aware of the thread
4. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bag-pouches-suggestion.13170/ Declined but both the Plushie bag and chocolate frog card book was implemented, promised a reply for the plushie bag and never got it
5. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/toggle-visibility-choose-your-own-view.15929/ - My idea was implemented but declined, I've suggested this way before I was forced to make a thread because I was ignored on other threads & Ariel never reached back about it
(Commented on original thread here - https://potterworldmc.com/threads/option-to-turn-off-player-visibility-in-flying.7713/ as well as here https://potterworldmc.com/threads/ditch-2x2-flying-hoops.15746/#post-94760 where I was simply ignored)
6. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/a...ple-alts-in-classes-ces-etc.12370/#post-80321 Completed but was never enforced in classes regularly, and consindering the discussion on this thread (https://potterworldmc.com/threads/house-boosting.16514/#post-97881) as well as many others, it should be revisited
7. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/event-scarfs.9048/#post-67549 Completed but wasn't followed through, you gave out the same scarves which made me make the thread at the time
8. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/banner-texture.12470/#post-81311 Completed, I'm still not fully happy with the redesign in a way that I think that the Hogwarts Banners should also have a background design like the House Banners do, because the logo on it's own is a bit empty. Also a bit off topic, but I'll officially make a suggestion here - Banner designs should not repeat, there's way than enough designs that can be used even if we stick with just a simple fade (personally made a banner sheet so that it's easy for staff to check which designs do exist so far https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...RX3MDn_cYrZ-zehnJ70IM/edit?pli=1#gid=29900023 )
9. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/rotation-of-dailies.14799/ Completed but I said how they should be fully randomized, not just a rotation. Won't get into details why that is better, it's worthless because it always gets overlooked. More dailies generally should be added. Also consider what I said in 2024 edit of this thread at the end about "daily blockers" https://potterworldmc.com/threads/leveling-then-vs-now.13872/#post-93616
10. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/the-balancing-of-the-extra-credit-activities.14644/ Kamer's and my comment got ignored, I believe it should be done. I won't repeat what I said there but this will be my official suggestion and a thread for it.
11. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/butterbrew-in-the-broomsticks-inn.15442/ Smaller thread but my comment got ignored
12, https://potterworldmc.com/threads/m...-in-the-guardian-quest-pt-4.14148/#post-88350 Completed but my comment got ignored, again, I'm suggesting for all the natural damages to be revisited.
13. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/new-arenas.11749/#post-82624 I originally suggested the dummy arena which was declined, but later on this thread https://potterworldmc.com/threads/add-dummy-to-dueling-classroom-to-test-damage.13907/ got accepted and completed.
14. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/fix-dueling.13873/ Lag is worse than ever
15. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/staff-items.8212/ Completed but there is so much inconsistency still. Potterworld needs to realize that before things didn't work like they work nowadays and items that were available for all players should never be taken away.
16. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/revert-to-the-old-potion-making-system.15148/ the last comment on the thread I made was seemingly ignored, but it is something I'm still standing behind today and I wrote there what I want to see in the new system so this will be my official thread for that idea.
17. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/put-an-end-to-events.15732/#post-94704 Declined as expected, but I wanna comment on by saying that I do believe events can be small and be successful (I genuinely enjoyed spring 2024 for example). I believe this is partially what PW should be doing in future. And my second suggestion regarding future of events is to possibly use permanent gameplay as a way of to kick off and celebrate an event (something like Azkaban in 2016, it was lauched during Halloween and then stayed there afterwards, it could be done again with Azkaban or Magical maze for anniversary)
18. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bring-back-the-decoration-of-the-courtyard-for-events.8423/ Also regarding events like the thread above, this time I ask the staff team to reconsider this decision as it's been proven that players do miss the decoration and it's definetely something that can be done for smaller events in future, rather than making any type of event builds .
19. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/a-suggestion-for-adding-parkour-spells-to-potterworldmc.14839/ Declined but I feel like my comment and idea was ignored, I discussed protego duo with Jacquas but never heard back, also a gliding spell would be dope.
20. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/make-daily-reward-claiming-automatic.13109/ Declined, generally I think the reasoning is a bit stupid, either way my last comment and alternative idea was ignored
21. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/more-chatter.14284/ Declined, but I would reconsider the decision, as well as thinking of an alternative. Just anything that happens automatically on the server that players can do on their own (something similar to Pierre, not literally the same thing but just something that happens automatically, it could be just a question in chat or something that players look for in game or epic chests appearing, literally anything)
22. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/class-and-arena-rules-automation.11702/ The discussion on the thread was unsurprisingly ignored again, I understand it's not easy to follow up with such threads but then what's the point of people discussing ideas anyway, if it's always gonna be ignored. At this point, I would seriously consider doing some sort of "automated class". Maybe it doesn't have to be labeled or be an actual class, but with the lack of overall activity on the server, something like this could be worth investing in. I know other HP servers have automated classes, and many servers generally have some automated happening.
23. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bring-remembering-survival-spell-back.9603/ Implemented but I was declined
23. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/budleigh-babberton-as-a-future-town.4840/ Recently declined suggestion, the reasoning doesn't make sense. Cease and desist should not be an excuse to build a small town like the many random towns we have already, and make some lore for it to reflect on the original. Let's not forget why the lore team is here, and what potterworld is.
24. https://potterworldmc.com/threads/i...e-dark-prison-as-a-gauntlet.12799/#post-98162 You keep crediting this person for the idea I originally suggested. EDIT - the threads got updated and declined because of cease and desist that limits the promotion of new content. Old azkaban was superior simply because of the gameplay, evergreen at that. It was more friendly to players of all levels since almost anyone could run through mobs or kill them as they were one shot. Repressed Evil is also happening in a canon location and I'm sure there's several ways to still promote the content. After all, the limited promotion outside the game isn't a good enough reason for me to just dismiss one of the best PW contents ever. Link to my original thread https://potterworldmc.com/threads/bring-back-azkaban.10865/
Enjoy polts, make it right this time
Last edited: